Welcome to my website.

Here I offer perspectives on a wide range of topics - politics, economy, current affairs and life in general.

Madhya Pradesh: Political Conversations at the Grassroots

20-11-2018published_dt 2018-11-20T10:59:13.054Z20-11-2018 16:29:13 IST
Updated On 20-11-2018 16:29:13 ISTmodified_dt 2018-11-20T10:59:13.173ZUpdated On 20-11-20182018-11-20T10:59:13.054Z20-11-2018 2018-11-20T10:59:13.054Z - 2018-11-20T10:59:13.173Z - 20-11-2018


The door is ajar in Madhya Pradesh. For the BJP to exit and the Congress to enter the corridors of power in Bhopal. That is the impression we gathered after travelling about 2,500 kilometres, touching interior areas of all the regions, starting, clockwise, from Malwa - both north and south, Madhya Bharath-Bhopal, Chambal-Gwalior, Bundelkhand, Bagelkhand and Maha Koshal between last week of October and the first week of November. 


We met farmers, farm labour, young people from both urban and rural areas, government employees, traders, female farm workers as well as home makers, professionals such as doctors and lawyers, small businessmen, advocates, and students in campuses. In the process, inescapably, we also met persons who are affiliated to major political parties. We have chosen not to meet political leaders or opinion makers. We spoke to all these segments in all the regions of the state at length. 


The method was not an administering of a questionnaire to generate quantitative data and arrive at percentages of vote share and number or seats of each party. It is  gathering of qualitative data in contradistinction to quantitative data. The method adopted was to conduct a series of rather long conversations with individuals and small groups (not exceeding 6 members) to understand their socio-economic condition in order to grasp what issues are salient for them and how their life experiences in grappling with those issues is likely to influence their voting choices. It is to sniff the air, so to speak, and see which way the wind is blowing. The overwhelming sense that our team gathered was that not a single person among those we met was indifferent to the upcoming election. They’re fully aware of the power they wield with their participation in it. Polling in this election, therefore, is likely to be on the higher side.


Acute farm distress is evident from the conversations in the countryside. ‘Bhavantar', state government’s scheme to give price support to farmers is unlikely to yield any substantial dividends to the ruling party. Deep resentment against price rise across the state is palpable. Anger against demonetisation is likely to wound the ruling establishment in the forthcoming Assembly elections. Lack of employment opportunities has alienated the youth in both rural and urban areas. In Malwa especially, the upper castes are decidedly opting to desert the BJP because of CM Chauhan’s 2016 ‘Koyi Maikalal...’ remark on the SC/ST Reservations issue. Many rural women said they would wait for their menfolk and other family members to tell them whom to vote. Or perhaps they did not want to reveal their mind to strangers from Hyderabad. Significantly, Hindu-Muslim issues, Ram Mandir, so called Rafel and Vyapam scams did not find any resonance with the voters. Professionals did mention about the Modi government’s attempts to weaken constitutional institutions.




Words like ‘Badlaav’ and ‘Parivartan’ are spoken in high decibels across the state, more prominently in the countryside. People who claimed to have voted for BJP last time said they wanted to shift to Congress this time. However, CM Shivraj Singh Chouhan remains popular. Those who want to vote against the BJP too acknowledge his good work. He comes across as a much popular leader and more influential with the voter than Prime Minister Modi in Madhya Pradesh. However, the possibility of Shivraj-fatigue neutralising the impact of his popularity and letting farm distress, price rise, unemployment and demonetisation effects to hurt the ruling party cannot be ruled out. 



There is still a significant chunk of undecided voters in the state. A good number of them are likely to go along with the tide that becomes evident nearer the polling day.  Majority of BJP voters said they’d vote in its favour to reward CM Chauhan’s work and not because of Modi. Those who preferred Congress are unconcerned about the CM face of the party. They’re prepared to take anyone who the Congress decides as CM after the elections. 



Karyakartas of BJP who participated in the conversations are assertive about the Party’s winning chances. Congress workers, on the other hand, are meek and lack confidence about their Party’s victory. It is the common unattached public who are more emphatic about the Congress party’s chances of forming government. 



Those who wanted BJP to win do not think that anti-incumbency could cut so deep as to unseat the party. But they’re prepared to accept that the party would return with much reduced strength in the 230 strong House, and the party’s candidates would win with reduced majorities in the constituencies. Even strong BJP supporters are not prepared to think that it would be an easy ride this time for the party. Political headwinds are strongly sensed by the BJP sympathisers and cadre.


Congress argument, if it has one, is not yet part of the political conversation among voters. CM Chouhan is at an advantage on this score as his work is known and talked about. Rahul Gandhi as a campaigner is yet to make an impression in the state. State Congress is organisationally an enfeebled entity as the party has been out of office for three consecutive terms. It is a divided house, unable to stitch together a uber narrative for the state and constituency/region specific variants of the campaign theme. BJP is ahead on this score.



The large number of conversations we had across the state in essence revealed that 2018 Madhya Pradesh election is not a wrestling contest between incumbent BJP and challenger Congress.



It is a spectacle of BJP contending with strong political headwinds in the form of anti-incumbency, farm distress, price rise, ill-effects of demonetisation, erosion of upper caste support especially in the Malwa region, unemployment and consequent youth apathy, and, Shivraj-fatigue. Neither PM Modi nor Congress President Rahul Gandhi are likely to play more than marginal roles in influencing the outcome of the poll.


Congress, our conversations across the state reveal, stands to benefit from the failure of BJP to contend with the headwinds. And the headwinds are blowing strongly in the state.


(The piece was jointly written by me and Kota Uma Devi and was first published in The Pioneer in its 17/11/2018 edition. )

I have added the video bytes that we collected during our travel to this blog post.